Courtesy Everett Collection Hollywood has always been synonymous with the movies, but film history buffs know that American cinema really started in New York — or, if you want to get picky, just across the Hudson River at Thomas Edison’s lab in New Jersey, where the Kinetoscope was invented.
One of the first narrative motion pictures, Edwin S. Porter’s The Great Train Robbery (1903), was shot partly at Edison’s studios in Manhattan. The earliest works of D.W. Griffith were also made in Manhattan, until Biograph built a bigger stage in the Bronx. “King of Comedy” Mack Sennett, who launched Charlie Chaplin’s career, started off at Biograph as well.
In other words, New York was Hollywood before Hollywood was Hollywood, and even if the studios soon moved west (although Netflix is now headed back east with its ginormous new facility in Jersey), the city has remained an ideal backdrop for some of the greatest films ever made, many directed by native New Yorkers. Martin Scorsese, Francis Ford Coppola, Spike Lee, Woody Allen, Sidney Lumet and John Cassavetes were all either born or grew up in one of the five boroughs. They shot some of their best work there, eschewing L.A. sunshine for the vibrance and grit of the Big Apple, which has no equal anywhere on earth.
To celebrate the release of three true-blooded NYC movies — Club Kid, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York and Queens boy James Gray’s latest crime drama, Paper Tiger (in addition to fabulous doc Once Upon a Time in Harlem) — THR critics have compiled and ranked a list of the 25 best films taking place in the city. To say there were more options than we had room for is an understatement; we started with a “shortlist” of around 100 titles we love or like, then debated and whittled down from there.
We’d like to think you can trust us — two of us are NYC-born-and-raised, one from Manhattan, one from Queens; one of us is a longtime transplant (25 years in Chelsea and counting); and one of us is a Californian with deep family roots in Brooklyn.
Our list could have consisted exclusively of works by the directors name-checked three paragraphs above, so we decided to limit the count to one film per filmmaker. We excluded documentaries (Welfare, On the Bowery and Paris Is Burning would have staked strong claims). And while we adore the classics that have stood the test of time, we also wanted to make room for some more recent films that are plugged in to the city’s ever-evolving set of joys and challenges.
There are countless beloved mainstream hits featuring NYC in significant ways — Tootsie, Kramer vs. Kramer, Ghost, Splash, Big, When Harry Met Sally, Ghostbusters, Moonstruck, Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, Working Girl, The Devil Wears Prada … we could go on. Those aren’t on our list, not because we don’t have affection for them (we do!), but because there were other titles we found more interesting, more distinctive in their use of the city as a setting and, in many cases, really a character in and of itself.
Some of our selections exude sheer energy. Others are marked by solitude and despair, chaos and murder, because New York is a town that has broken many a soul. Brooklyn-born Jay-Z may have said it best in “Empire State of Mind,” undoubtedly the NYC anthem of our time: “Eight million stories out there in the naked city; it’s a pity half of y’all won’t make it.” That lyric references Jules Dassin’s 1948 noir The Naked City, one of 10 honorable mentions — films that could have made the list if we had finalized it another day. The others: All That Jazz, Escape From New York, Girlfriends, It Should Happen to You, Klute, Marty Supreme, Midnight Cowboy, Saturday Night Fever and Tiny Furniture.
And here are our 25 favorites.
-
‘A Thousand and One’ (2023)

Image Credit: Focus Features/Courtesy Everett Collection Set against the background of rapidly gentrifying 1990s New York — Brooklyn and Harlem in particular — debuting director A.V. Rockwell’s atmospherically charged Sundance winner gives Teyana Taylor a powerhouse showcase as Inez, a hair stylist and single mother fresh from a stint at Rikers and determined to get her 6-year-old boy out of the foster care system by whatever means necessary.
Tracing a decade-plus in the marginalized lives of the mother and son, this moving character study watches Inez evolve from youthful bravado to hard-won self-possession. It also acutely observes painful rips in the fabric of New York City life for the economically disadvantaged and racial minorities, under the aggressive policies of Rudy Giuliani’s mayoral administration and on through the rampant development and discriminatory policing of the Bloomberg years.