Diagnostic dilemma: A woman heard voices telling her she had a brain tumor ‪—‬ and scans confirmed she did

A woman sought medical care after she started hearing unfamiliar voices. (Image credit: D-Keine via Getty Images)

• Copy link
• Facebook
• X
• Whatsapp
• Reddit
• Pinterest
• Flipboard
• Email

Share this article 0 Join the conversation Follow us Add us as a preferred source on Google Newsletter Sign up for the Live Science daily newsletter now

Get the world’s most fascinating discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.

Become a Member in Seconds

Unlock instant access to exclusive member features.

Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

You are now subscribed

Your newsletter sign-up was successful

Want to add more newsletters?

Join the club

Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards.

Explore An account already exists for this email address, please log in. Subscribe to our newsletter

The patient: A woman in her 40s in the United Kingdom

The symptoms: One day, as the woman was reading, she heard an unfamiliar voice say, "Please don't be afraid. I know it must be shocking for you to hear me speaking to you like this, but this is the easiest way I could think of. My friend and I used to work at the Children's Hospital, Great Ormond Street, and we would like to help you."

The woman said the disembodied voice then attempted to convince her of its sincerity by providing three pieces of information she did not know and suggesting that she check their veracity as "proof" that the voice could convey a truthful message. The woman looked up the facts and confirmed that they were correct.

Article continues below

What happened next: The woman did not know where the voice was coming from; she was frightened and thought she was having a mental health crisis. So she visited her general practitioner, who gave her an urgent referral to a psychiatric clinic.

The diagnosis: At the clinic, a psychiatrist diagnosed the woman with "functional hallucinatory psychosis," a break with reality for which there is no clear physical cause, like a brain injury. (By comparison, "organic disorders with psychosis" stem from structural defects in the brain or from brain damage from conditions such as neurodegenerative disease or stroke.)

The treatment: The psychiatrist recommended counseling, as well as treatment with thioridazine, an antipsychotic medication. After two weeks, the voices disappeared, the psychiatrist wrote in a report of the case.

The patient then went on vacation. Although she was still taking thioridazine, the voices came back, telling her she needed to go home immediately for medical treatment.

Sign up for the Live Science daily newsletter now

Get the world’s most fascinating discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.

Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors

Upon her return home, the woman continued hearing the voices. These voices gave her an address to visit, which turned out to be a hospital department that performed CT scans, and then urged her to schedule a brain scan because she had a tumor. She was upset when she returned to her psychiatrist's office, and he ordered a scan to reassure her.

A CT scan revealed a tumor in the tissues covering the woman's brain. (This is a stock image.) (Image credit: NurPhoto via Getty Images)

"The request was initially declined, on the grounds that there was no clinical justification for such an expensive investigation," he wrote in the report. "It was also implied that I had gone a little overboard, believing what my patient's hallucinatory voices were telling her."

But the scan was ultimately approved, and its results aligned with what the hallucinations had said: The woman had a type of tumor called a parafalcine meningioma, which grows between the two hemispheres of the brain. These growths appear in the meninges, the layers of tissue that cover the brain and spinal cord.

Her psychiatrist and a consulting neurosurgeon recommended surgery to remove the tumor, and the voices "told her that they were fully in agreement with that decision," according to the report. Surgeons removed the growth, which measured 2.5 inches (6.4 centimeters) long and 1.5 inches (3.8 centimeters) wide.

As she regained consciousness after the operation, the voices relayed a final message: "We are pleased to have helped you. Goodbye."

The patient recovered with no complications. She was taken off thioridazine immediately after the operation, and the voices did not return. Twelve years after her surgery, the woman called her psychiatrist to wish him a happy holiday season and said she had been symptom-free ever since the procedure.

What makes the case unique: Brain lesions, including tumors, have long been associated with psychiatric disorders and mental health issues, including anxiety disorders, cognitive dysfunction, depression and schizophrenia. Lesions have also been linked to visual and auditory hallucinations — for instance, in one unusual case, brain lesions contributed to a woman's perception of human faces as dragon-like.

However, prior to the U.K. woman's case, no other known case report had described hallucinatory voices diagnosing a previously unknown medical condition while also offering comfort and guidance for treatment, according to the patient's attending psychiatrist.

"This is the first and only instance I have come across in which hallucinatory voices sought to reassure the patient of their genuine interest in her welfare, offered her a specific diagnosis (there were no clinical signs that would have alerted anyone to the tumour), directed her to the type of hospital best equipped to deal with her problem, expressed pleasure that she had at last received the treatment they desired for her, bid her farewell, and thereafter disappeared," the psychiatrist wrote in the report.

He presented this case at a conference, where several of his peers suggested that, because the tumor was so large, the patient may have felt something that caused her to subconsciously suspect something was wrong. (Notably, the brain itself does not contain pain-sensing nerves, but the meninges that cover the brain do.)

OTHER DILEMMAS

• Giant 'stone' in a man's bladder looked like an ostrich egg
• Rare semen allergy may have caused woman's infertility
• Man caught rabies from organ transplant after donor was scratched by skunk

Perhaps her anxiety manifested as voices that seemed to know more than she did but that were actually only drawing her attention to information that she didn't realize she already had, the conference attendees mused.

The fact that the voices vanished after the tumor's removal "showed that these symptoms were at least directly related to the presence of the lesion — and may, in fact, have been produced by the lesion itself," the psychiatrist wrote.

For more intriguing medical cases, check out our Diagnostic Dilemma archives.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and is not meant to offer medical advice.

Article Sources

Azuonye, I. O. (1997). A difficult case: Diagnosis made by Hallucinatory Voices. BMJ, 315(7123), 1685–1686. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.315.7123.1685

Mindy WeisbergerLive Science Contributor

Mindy Weisberger is a science journalist and author of "Rise of the Zombie Bugs: The Surprising Science of Parasitic Mind-Control" (Hopkins Press). She formerly edited for Scholastic and was a channel editor and senior writer for Live Science. She has reported on general science, covering climate change, paleontology, biology and space. Mindy studied film at Columbia University; prior to LS, she produced, wrote and directed media for the American Museum of Natural History in NYC. Her videos about dinosaurs, astrophysics, biodiversity and evolution appear in museums and science centers worldwide, earning awards such as the CINE Golden Eagle and the Communicator Award of Excellence. Her writing has also appeared in Scientific American, The Washington Post, How It Works Magazine and CNN.

View More

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Logout LATEST ARTICLES

1. 1Triassic croc relative from Ghost Ranch, New Mexico finally identified after nearly 80 years in museum basement
2. 2There were 'audible screams of delight': Why Artemis II sightings of meteor flashes on the moon have scientists giddy
3. 3Physicists just witnessed pinpricks of darkness moving faster than the speed of light ‪—‬ without breaking the laws of relativity
4. 4Mini lake meets snowy rim of Canada's oldest ice mass — Earth from space
5. 5Stone Age tombs in Scotland reveal 'webs of descent' among male relatives