The Colts were one of the best teams in the NFL over the first half of last season and entered their Week 11 bye with an 8-2 record. But that's when the schedule turned brutal, with both games against the Texans and Jaguars down the stretch along with road trips to Kansas City and Seattle plus a home game against the 49ers. To make matters worse, starting QB Daniel Jones suffered an Achilles injury that left the team scrambling at quarterback. Jones' recovery will likely dictate how 2026 goes for Indianapolis, as the Colts seem likely to head into the season with Riley Leonard and Anthony Richardson again behind him on the depth chart.
We're taking a look at everything you need to know before making Indianapolis Colts futures bets below, including odds, trends, 2026 schedule, offseason changes and more before sharing our preseason betting strategy for the team. Odds are via DraftKings.
Fans interested in betting on NFL and Super Bowl futures should check out the latest DraftKings promo code.
Indianapolis Colts 2026 odds
Odds to …June 1FebGo Over win total7.5 (-130)8.5 (+105)Go Under win total7.5 (+110)8.5 (-125)Miss playoffs-215 Make playoffs+170 Win AFC South+390 Win AFC+2800 Win Super Bowl+6500+6000The market hasn't been impressed with the Colts' offseason, as their win total market projection has dropped from just shy of 8.5 to slightly better than 7.5. However, if Jones continues to receive positive health updates after participating in drills at OTAs, that could change as Shane Steichen has managed to win at least eight games in each of his three seasons coaching the team while juggling quarterbacks.
Indianapolis Colts futures trends
YearSuper Bowl oddsWin totalResultActual winsFinish2025+100007.5Over83rd, AFC South2024+80008.5Under82nd, AFC South2023+125006.5Over92nd, AFC South2022+22409.5Under43rd, AFC South2021+35009Push92nd, AFC SouthSince last winning the division title in 2014, the Colts have managed fewer than seven wins twice and more than nine wins twice, with six seasons at eight or nine wins. The defining trait of that period has been instability at quarterback, as the team has finished with seven different leading passers in seven seasons since Andrew Luck's surprise retirement.
If you want to wager on NFL futures, you have to check out the latest FanDuel promo code.
Indianapolis Colts 2025 season review
RecordPy WinsYds/play (Rk)Opp y/p (Rk)DVOA (Rk)8-99.735.78 (8)5.34 (17)18.9 (5)The Colts ranking fifth in DVOA suggests their first half shouldn't just be written off as solely due to their schedule, and Pythagorean wins (based on point differential) put them closer to a 10-win team than an 8-9 team. Not only did Indy rank top 10 in yards per pass and run play on offense, the Colts played strong situational football and led the league in goal to go situations. The defense finished second in yards allowed per rush but struggled more against the pass and ranked just 26th in sack rate.
Indianapolis Colts 2026 offseason review
LostAddedDraftedQB RBTyler Goodson, Ameer Abdullah, Salvon Ahmed Seth McGowan (7)WRMichael Pittman, DJ MontgomeryNick Westbrook-IhkineDeion Burks (7)TE Carson Towt OLBraden Smith, Danny Pinter Jalen Farmer (4)DLNeville Gallimore, Eric Johnson, Chris WormleyColby Wooden, Jerry Tillery, Derrick Nnadi EDGEKwity Paye, Samson Ebukam, Tyquan LewisArden Key, Michael ClemonsGeorge Gumbs (5), Caden Curry (6)LBZaire Franklin, Germaine Pratt, Jacob Phillips, Buddy JohnsonAkeem Davis-Gaither, Devin VeresukCJ Allen (2), Bryce Boettcher (4)CBKenny Moore, Chris LammonsCam Taylor-Britt, Rob Carter SNick Cross, Rodney Thomas, George OdomJuanyeh Thomas, Jonathan OwensA.J. Haulcy (3)STAFFMost of the Colts' focus this offseason was on defense, including bringing in two potential new starters with their first two picks in linebacker C.J. Allen and safety A.J. Cauley. Not as much was done to address the mediocre pass rush with Arden Key the primary new face. On offense, the sole move of note involves bringing in Nick Westbrook-Ikhine to replace Michael Pittman in the offense, with the team's loss at right tackle expected to be addressed internally after Jalen Travis played well in limited action as a rookie.
Before you wager on NFL or Super Bowl futures, head over to our BetMGM promo code to see a great offer.
Indianapolis Colts 2026 schedule
WeekOppNotes1BAL 2@KC 3HOU 4@WASLondon5@PIT 6TEN 7@MIN 8@JAC 9DAL 10MIA 11@HOUThu12NYG 13bye 14@PHI 15@TEN 16CIN 17@CLE 18JACThe Colts have a brutal three-game start to the season with facing the Ravens, Chiefs and Texans before a trip to London, so things could get ugly early, particularly if Jones isn't ready for Week 1. They'll get to scrap a road game for international play, and the schedule gets more manageable after that, with plenty of winnable home games on tap.
If you want to tail R.J. White and other SportsLine and CBS experts, check out the latest Caesars Sportsbook promo code.
Indianapolis Colts futures picks
- Under 7.5 wins (+110)
Steichen has worked wonders with what he's been given during his tenure as quarterbacks have come and gone, but this team appears to be a house of cards ready to fall. I can't expect the offense to look anything like it did last year with Jones coming off a major injury plus questionable receiving depth, and this team could be one or two key injuries away from focusing on the pursuit of the No. 1 overall pick, particularly with a tough opening two months on the schedule. Those looking to take a little more risk can throw a sprinkle on the Colts to finish last in the division at +245.
Add CBS Sports on Google Join the Conversation comments
